Navigating the Great Lakes - Lesson Plan

Lesson Plan

Lesson Goals

Essential Questions

• What were some of the challenges that the sailors faced?'
• What was the importance of the Great Lakes on shipping in the 1840s-1900s?

Enduring Understandings:

• The problems and solutions of sailing through history.
• The role of the Great Lakes in shipping goods, people, and materials.
• Geographical and geological details of the Great Lakes and identify them identify the lakes by name.

Objectives:

By the end of the lesson, students will be able to:

• Students will be able to explain how all the Great Lakes are connected and why that matters for shipping between the lakes and from the ocean.
  • Students should be able to recognize the physical challenges of sailing on the Great Lakes such as waterfalls, canals, etc.
• Students will be able to identify 3 challenges the early sailors faced while transporting cargo of copper, people, and supplies. (Fog, blizzards, gales, collisions, sandbars, rocky shores, fire, smoke, and explosions on board)
• Students will be able to name the 5 Great Lakes (Superior, Michigan, Huron, Erie, Ontario) and several shipping ports.
• Students will be able to explain why the Great Lakes are so important for shipping.

Lesson Planning

Instructional Time:

• 30 minutes to 1 hour

*Activities can be done at the instructor’s pace as well as be done in individual segments and/or across multiple days

Recommended Materials:

• Computers
• Paper
• Brass Fasteners
• Paperclips

Preparation:

• Print enough copies of the board game activity so that students can work in groups of 2-4.
• Cut out the spinner on each board game printout and insert the brass fastener through the center. Allow the paperclip to spin freely on the brass fastener. (Image of complete spinner below)
• Navigate to the Keweenaw National Historical Park webpage by following the link located in the resources section toward the bottom of this lesson plan.

Learning Standards, Intelligences, and Assessment

Learning Standards:

Michigan K-12 English Language Arts Standards:
W 4.3
Write narratives to develop real or imagined experiences or events using effective technique, descriptive details, and clear event sequences.
W 4.4
Produce clear and coherent writing in which the development and organization are appropriate to task, purpose, and audience.

Michigan K-12 Speaking and Listening Standards:
SL 4.1
Engage effectively in a range of collaborative discussions (one-on-one, in groups, and teacher-led) with diverse partners on grade 4 topics and texts, building on others’ ideas and expressing their own clearly.

Michigan K-12 Language Standards:
L 4.1
Demonstrate command of the conventions of standard English grammar and usage when writing or speaking.
L 4.2
Demonstrate command of the conventions of standard English capitalization, punctuation, and spelling when writing.

Michigan K-12 Social Studies Standards:
4 – H3.0.1  
Use primary and secondary sources to explain how migration and immigration affected and continue to affect the growth of Michigan.
4 – H3.0.1  
Use historical inquiry questions to investigate the development of Michigan’s major economic activities from statehood to present.

Michigan K-12 Geography Standards:
4 – G4.0.3  
Describe some of the movements of resources, goods, people, and information to, from, or within the United States, and explain the reasons for the movements.
 

Intelligences:

People learn in a variety of different ways and understanding these ways can help meet the needs of learners and contribute to a successful learning environment. Howard Gardner, an American psychologist, developed the idea behind people having a variety of intelligences impacting how they learn. This is referred to a Garner’s Multiple Intelligences. The activities in this lesson will focus on various intelligences as noted in each activity.
 

Assessment:

Students will explain to partners why the Great Lakes are so important to shipping, the names of the Great Lakes, and dangers of sailing on the lakes.
 

 

 

Eagle Harbor Lighthouse, Keweenaw County Historical Society

NPS Photo

Navigating the Great Lakes with the Keweenaw County Historical Society

Background

Not familiar with the Keweenaw Peninsula? Start here:

• Keweenaw National Historical Park Website
• Keweenaw County Historical Society

This lesson plan focuses on the Keweenaw County Historical Society, or KCHS for short. KCHS is made up of a group of dedicated volunteers who work to preserve and showcase 11 historic sites on the Keweenaw Peninsula in the Upper Peninsula in Michigan, United States. The various sites KCHS maintains are not only known for copper mining, but also shipping, commercial fishing, lumber, and even maritime history.

Although there are many themes that KCHS embodies, the focus of this lesson is going to be on the importance of shipping in the Great Lakes. From 1840 to around 1900, ships were the only way to move people, goods, copper, and other supplies into and out of towns on the Keweenaw Peninsula. Sailors faced great challenges and navigated safely using lighthouses. The Great Lakes waters flow from 602 feet all the way down to sea level. Ships are unable to pass over waterfalls such as Niagara Falls, and so locks were built to efficiently move ships between lakes.

In this lesson students will focus on learning about the danger and difficulties of shipping (fog, blizzards, gales, collisions, sandbars, rocky shores, fire, smoke, and explosions on board), the five great lakes and shipping ports, the locks that allow ships to transition between lakes, and major shipping events.

 

Introduction Video:

Activity Objective
Gain an understanding to basic information about shipping on the Great Lakes.

1. Play introductory video to the entire class.

2. Hold a discussion with students after the video. Ask questions such as:

   1. What are some challenges sailors faced when sailing across the Great Lakes? (Storms, fog, blizzards, gales, fires, etc.)

   2. How did lighthouses and fog signals help sailors stay safe? (Helped with navigation, helped sailors stay away from rocks and the shore)

   3. Why do you think shipping on the Great Lakes is so important? (Able to transport materials pretty far inland by water.)

 

• 

  Intro Video for the KCHS Maritime History Module

  Intro Video for the KCHS Maritime History Module

  Duration:

  2 minutes, 47 seconds

 

Video Tour of Lighthouse

Activity Objective
Understand the role of lighthouses and fog signals in ship safety and navigation.

1. Start by playing the video tour for the class to watch together.

2. After watching, lead a short discussion on the following questions, or similar questions:

   1. Why do you think the lighthouse is colored a specific color? (to stand out against the land so that sailors can easily see it during the day)

   2. What do you think the other buildings around the lighthouse are for? (housing for the lighthouse keeper and family, assistant keeper, building for the fog signal)

 

• 

  Tour of Eagle Harbor Lighthouse

  Video tour of the Eagle Harbor Lighthouse tower and living quarters.

  Duration:

  2 minutes, 7 seconds

 

Writing a Lighthouse Keeper’s Log

Writing activity instructions

Activity Objective
Think creatively and apply previously learned material to an open-ended prompt on safety and navigation in sailing the Great Lakes.

1. Hand out printouts of the Lighthouse Keeper’s Log template. Introduce the activity as the students are now Lighthouse Keepers in Eagle Harbor, Michigan. Imagine living at a lighthouse in the Great Lakes region in the early 1900s, What challenges might you face? How has technology evolved? What would you observe every day?

2. Give them time to write out a Lighthouse Keepers Log that they can take home at the end of the day.

 

Shipping Board Game

Activity Objective

Understand how slow and difficult the process of shipping on the Great Lakes is.

1. Gather students into groups of 2-4.

2. Hand out printouts of the game board, paper pieces, and spinner to each group.

3. Read the instructions below and have the students start playing the game.

   1. Shipping Board Game Instructions:

      1. Cut out all pieces and spinning wheel.

      2. All pieces start at the same port, either Duluth or Detroit.

      3. One at a time, take turns spinning the wheel. Move the amount of spaces the wheel tells you to.

      4. If you are at a port and the wheel tells you to move backward, stay where you are.

      5. The first to the opposite port wins!

4. Once everyone is done, lead a short discussion which could include the following questions:

   1. What did you think of the game?

   2. Is there any strategy or does it feel random?

   3. Based on this game, do you think sailing on Lake Superior is easy or difficult?

Game Board Template
Spinner Template

 

Map Exploration - Coming soon!

Activity Objective
Understand the historic routes ships on Lake Superior would take to transport people and cargo.

1. Pull up the shipping map on the Keweenaw National Historical Park website.

2. Guide them through the following questions, or similar questions, that they discuss in small groups:

   1. Why do you think the route shown on the map is the route that sailors took? Why wouldn’t they stick closer to land? (Going out across open water in straight lines is faster, trying to avoid rocky shores or shallow spots, etc.)

   2. How do you think captains knew they were close to land? What if it was foggy or dark out and they couldn’t see the land? (Lighthouses, fog signals)

 

Additional Student Learning Opportunities:

Visit the Keweenaw County Historical Society! Visit their website to look at the different sites they offer, hours, directions, and more!