The Work of Water
There are several explanations of how the Water Gap formed, but essentially, erosion has removed the rock from what is now the Water Gap
Headwater Erosion (and stream-capturing)explains that the folding of the rocks layers resulted in a weakened spot in the ridge. Creeks flowing down the mountain eventually slowly eroded their way back through the ridge until they cut the whole way through and "captured" a river on the other side of the ridge. (See How the Gap Formed at right)
Superposition explains that creeks eroded an ever deepening channel; the folding or weakening of the rock is not involved.